Some kind of dispute was behind the massacre early Sunday morning of six young people by an off-duty sheriff’s deputy, officials in Crandon, Wisconsin said today.
The deputy, Tyler Peterson, acted alone in the shootings of the six, who were students at Crandon High School or recent graduates, according to J.B. Van Hollen, the state attorney general, who spoke at an early afternoon news conference in the school’s auditorium today.
Mr. Van Hollen said Mr. Peterson, 20, died later on Sunday, but would not say whether he was shot by police who had located him in a nearby town or took his own life.
He said the victims were attending a party and that Mr. Peterson was also present. “There was an argument,” said Mr. Van Hollen.
He said Mr. Peterson left the gathering, but returned with an automatic rifle, similar to one used by the sheriff’s department. About 30 rounds were fired, killing the six and wounding one. He said Mr. Peterson fired at a Crandon police car that apparently was responding to reports of shots being fired. The officer in the car was wounded by breaking glass, but was not seriously injured. Mr. Peterson then left the scene, he said.
Officials said the shooter apparently had a previous relationship with one of the young women at the gathering, but would not provide details.
Mr. Peterson also worked part-time on the Crandon police force. Its chief, John Dennee, said today that Mr. Peterson had met the state requirements to be a police officer and said “we had no indication” that he would extract murderous revenge. No psychological screening was performed in his hiring, Chief Dennee said.
After the shooting, Mr. Peterson had some telephone conversations with Leon Stenz, the Forest County district attorney, about surrendering to police, but could not reach an agreement. Mr. Stenz said Mr. Peterson seemed calm on the phone, and “he understood the situation he was in.”
A local pastor, Bill Farr, read a statement from Mr. Peterson’s family at the news conference, saying that the family was shocked at the incident, which they said “was not the Tyler we knew and loved.” The family said it felt “a tremendous amount of guilt and shame for the acts Tyler committed” as well as sorrow and grief for the victims and their families.
Documents fill in lost hours after gunman killed six in Crandon
Police faced 'uphill odds' in 7,000-mile manhunt for Tyler Peterson
By Kate McGinty - PostCrescent.com
CRANDON — What
started with the shootings of seven people at a
house party Oct. 7 ended nearly 10 hours later
with police handcuffing a dead man outside a
cabin eight miles away.
In between, a massive manhunt involving dozens
of law enforcement officers, aircraft and dogs
played out as police scoured more than 7,000
miles of northern Wisconsin roads in search of
one man. The drama of those lost hours
emerges for the first time in State Patrol
reports and those of several sheriff's
departments requested by The Post-Crescent, as
well as more than 1,200 pages of investigation
reports released this past week by Atty. Gen.
J.B. Van Hollen. The state Department of
Justice documents were made public four months
to the day after Tyler Peterson, a 20-year-old
off-duty Forest County sheriff's deputy, shot to
death six people, including his ex-girlfriend,
Jordanne Murray, 18, and critically wounded a
seventh, Charlie Neitzel, 21. Also killed were: Aaron Smith,
20, Bradley Schultz, 20, Lindsey Stahl, 14,
Lianna Thomas, 18, and Katrina McCorkle, 18. They tell the story of the
officers who searched for Peterson after he fled
from the scene of the crime, spurring a tense
manhunt that started as most of the state slept
and was captured on teletypes, cell phones and
mobile computers. "Throughout the early morning,
law enforcement agencies from throughout the
state were contacted, were en route and were
fanning out to protect communities and locate
Peterson," said Mike Myszewski, acting
administrator for the Department of Justice's
Division of Criminal Investigation. "Law enforcement faced uphill
odds in locating Peterson." Search and locate Phones began ringing across
the state hours before sunrise. Cars flooded the roads as
early as 3:39 a.m. to head toward Crandon from
across the state. Two pilots were called in to
begin aerial searches. Eighteen agencies in all
responded to a plea for help from Forest County,
including state agents from Madison, Michigan
state police and sheriff's deputies from
Washington County, 213 miles away. "Didn't get any specifics as
to how many vehicles, but he said lots," one
trooper wrote that morning. Later, police would say
Peterson drove "aimlessly" around Forest,
Langlade and Lincoln counties. The dozens of police cars
almost mimicked his behavior. Sgt. Travis Wanless, who
wrote a detailed summary of the State Patrol's
involvement following the initial investigation,
said officers narrow their searches to specific
areas, then start driving. "We just have our units kind
of respond to that general area and hope we kind
of stumble across him," Wanless said. As the officers drove
cautiously, searching for any sign of a murder
suspect or his vehicle, they wrestled with an
unfamiliar and overwhelming feeling, Wanless
said. "I don't even know how really
to describe it. … An (initial) adrenaline rush
would be a way to describe it, especially
because of that incident in particular. That's a
pretty serious offense," he said. Wanless, who only once
referred to Peterson by name, and even then
called him "Mr. Peterson," said the prospect of
actually finding their mass murderer was
unsettling. The anxiety was heightened by the
knowledge that Peterson, an avid hunter, was
carrying several weapons. "There's always the thought
in the back of your mind, 'What am I going to do
when I locate him? Or if I do locate him?'" he
said. "You're kind of going over the 'what if'
scenarios in your mind. 'What if he starts
shooting at me?'… You name it, it could probably
happen. "Our training does somewhat
prepare us … but to actually be put in a
situation, it is totally different." Renegade deputy As the manhunt grew, State
Patrol dispatchers took the lead organizing the
search. They began listing the times and places
officers were to begin duty and relaying
information about Peterson and his vehicle. Their suspect's law
enforcement background, though, was troubling:
Deputy Peterson, as the dispatchers frequently
called him, might overhear. "This is not for radio
broadcast as Deputy Peterson has his portable,"
dispatchers said repeatedly. Without the option of police
radios, State Patrol officers turned to mobile
computers and personal cell phones. Peterson's intimate knowledge
of police techniques definitely hampered the
search, Myszewski said. "He knew the area very well
and had access to law enforcement communications
through the radio he kept in his truck. If
police talked over the radio, he would hear,"
Myszewski said. Making the search even more
difficult, Peterson kept in touch by cell phone
with friends and family, and sometimes his
pursuers. He usually refused to tell his family
and friends where he was for fear they would
turn him in — and he lied to police about his
whereabouts to throw them off his trail. "Peterson was actively giving
misinformation to those he spoke with,
proactively trying to throw law enforcement off
of his trail," Myszewski said. One of his boldest ploys was
a call to the Vilas County Sheriff's Department
in which he identified himself as a member of
the Forest County Sheriff's Department to
provide false information to searchers. Peterson, who responded "yep"
to most questions, asked the dispatcher about
the "renegade deputy" responsible for the
shootings in Crandon. "What did you have for a
vehicle description?" Peterson asked. "Yeah,
it's going to be a 2004, red F-150 now. … We
don't (have a plate number) as of yet." When the dispatcher asked if
he knew what time the shootings had occurred,
Peterson pretended to look at a case file. "I think about midnight. I'd
have to look up the complaint. … Hold on,"
Peterson said. The dispatcher asked if the
shooter had tried to kill people, curiosity
evident in her voice as she learned for the
first time that it was a deputy who was being
sought by authorities. "Six of 'em," Peterson
answered. "Six of 'em?" "Yep." "And they're dead?" "Yep." Desperation grows More than four hours after
the shootings, the dozens of searchers on the
road were no closer to finding him. Dispatcher Debra Seefeldt
began reciting what became a repeated warning
that searchers use "extreme caution." She would later add details —
Peterson probably had his service weapon, he was
an avid hunter — but Seefeldt repeated the
cautionary bulletin seven times in 11 minutes. Though they remained calm and
organized, dispatchers also seemed to be getting
desperate. Some began questioning if Peterson
had long fled the state, even the country. At 6:58 a.m., a State Patrol
dispatcher alerted border patrol in
International Falls, Minn., and Grand Forks, N.D.
"Advise (them) suspect possibly trying to get
into Canada," the dispatcher said. Peterson, though, had doubled
back and showed up at a cabin in Argonne, only
eight miles from the shooting, at about 7:50
a.m. Police had no clue, and kept
searching. As late as 8:21 a.m., dispatchers
said: "At this time, still no location of his
whereabouts." About the same time,
dispatchers told searching officers that
Peterson's cell phone calls had been traced to
Long Lake, then later Iron River, Mich. That
meant, dispatchers said, he was within five
miles of the tower in Iron River. Though the reason for the
misleading call traces remains unclear,
dispatchers would soon realize Peterson was much
closer than they realized. An end in sight At 10:02 a.m. — 7 hours and
16 minutes after Peterson killed his ex-girlfriend
and five of her friends — the officers searching
for Peterson were finally alerted their manhunt
was over. Their suspect had been found:
"Update on Deputy Peterson. We believe Peterson
may be located in our county at a cabin, and we
are staging at this time for attempting to
apprehend him. We have the rifle, and he is
believed to still have the pistol." A co-owner of the property
had called the police, saying Peterson had shown
up at her cabin. Confrontation loomed. Armored
vehicles surrounded the cabin, nearby roads were
blocked off and Forest County requested a K-9
unit. At about 12:30 p.m., Peterson
walked hurriedly into the woods near the cabin.
A sniper fired just before he vanished from
sight, not knowing whether the shot found its
mark. Three more shots, quieter than the first,
rang out from the direction Peterson had gone. A
tactical team rushed toward the woods, yelling
for Peterson to surrender. They found him lying on his
back in the tall grass. One agent stepped on
Peterson's right arm to hold it down as he
plucked the gun from his hand. They rolled him
over and handcuffed him. Only then did they realize
they had handcuffed a dead man. On the scanners, the long,
narrative descriptions of Peterson ceased.
Dispatchers returned to short, staccato updates
loaded with impersonal police language. "One, two, three, four shots
fired. Subject in woods northbound." "Suspect 10-95 at this time." "Advised situation in Forest
County is over. Subject committed suicide." "Cancel APB on Deputy
Peterson." Timeline of events on
Sunday, Oct. 7 12 a.m.: Tyler Peterson
drops off two friends. 2:30 a.m.: Peterson
arrives at a duplex, 201 N. Hazeldell Ave.,
Apt. B, Crandon. An argument ensues with ex-
girlfriend Jordanne Murray, who Peterson
accused of having a relationship with
another man. Murray demands Peterson leave. 2:43 a.m.: Peterson
leaves duplex and retrieves a police AR-15
rifle. 2:47 a.m.: Crandon police
officer Greg Carter reports to dispatch that
he heard gunshots. 2:48 a.m.: Peterson
emerges from duplex and shoots at Carter,
hitting the squad car's windshield. 2:51 a.m.: Someone inside
the duplex reports gunshots. 2:53 a.m.: Medics from
Laona and Wabeno paged to scene. 2:55 a.m.: Dispatcher
tells police that shooter is at 201 N.
Hazeldell Ave., a neighboring residence. 3 a.m.: Peterson starts
to drive to see his brother, then begins to
drive "aimlessly'' around Lincoln, Forest
and Langlade counties in northern Wisconsin.
Peterson later tries to throw police off his
trail by calling in false reports of his
location. 3:01 a.m.: Ambulances
arrive at duplex. 3:09 a.m.: A Forest
County deputy leaves a message on Peterson's
cell phone requesting a return call. 3:10 a.m.: Chief Deputy
Ken Van Cleve of the Forest County Sheriff's
Department leaves a message on Peterson's
cell phone requesting Peterson meet or call
him. 4:20 a.m.: Local police
agencies request help from the state
Department of Justice's Division of Criminal
Investigation. 4:30 a.m.: DCI staff
members head toward the scene. 5:13 a.m.: Tyler Peterson
tells authorities there is no "taking back
what he did." 5:58 a.m.: Authorities
request State Patrol troopers for help with
crowd control and scene containment. 7:50 a.m.: Peterson goes
to a cabin in Argonne where his friends are. 7:55 a.m.: Peterson, who
seems intoxicated, tells people at the cabin
what he did. Peterson says he will turn
himself in to Crandon Police Chief John
Dennee. Sometime later, one of the people at
the cabin puts Peterson's AR-15 on the porch
swing after Peterson gives it up. 8:30 a.m.: Peterson
leaves cabin to meet with family members. 9:15 a.m.: Peterson
returns to cabin. One of the cabin's
occupants leaves, calls 911 and returns. 9:30 a.m.: People in
cabin notice Peterson still has a pistol on
his hip. 9:40 a.m.: Steve Peterson,
Tyler Peterson's father, calls his son but
the call goes to voicemail. 9:56 a.m.: Tyler Peterson
makes first of two calls to Forest County
sheriff. 12:31 p.m.: Peterson is
shot in the left bicep, presumably by police,
and is found a short time later with three
apparently self-inflicted pistol wounds to
the head. About 4 p.m.: Police
confirm the names of the six shooting
victims who died and Peterson's death to the
residents gathered at Praise Chapel
Community Church in Crandon. Sources: State Department of
Justice, The Post-Crescent