Murderpedia has thousands of hours of work behind it. To keep creating
new content, we kindly appreciate any donation you can give to help
the Murderpedia project stay alive. We have many
plans and enthusiasm
to keep expanding and making Murderpedia a better site, but we really
need your help for this. Thank you very much in advance.
Dominique
COTTREZ
Classification: Infanticide
Characteristics:
"Denial of pregnancy"
Number of victims: 8
Date of murder: 1989 - 2006
Date of arrest:
July 2010
Date of birth: 1965
Victim profile:
Her newborn infants
Method of murder:
Smothering
Location: Villers-au-Tertre,
Nord department,
France
Dominique Cottrez,
45, is a French woman who admitted killing 8 of her newborn
infants. In July 2010, two of the bodies were discovered in
plastic bags by new owners working in the garden of a house
Dominique and her husband, Pierre-Marie Cottrez, previously
occupied.
When police contacted the
Cottrez family to question them about the discoveries, Dominique
immediately admitted that the bodies belonged to two infants she
had given birth to. She also told police that six more infants'
bodies were hidden in the garage. All were born over an
approximately 17-year period between 1989 and 2006 or 2007.
French prosecutors announced on July 29, 2010
that Dominique had been indicted on murder charges. Her husband,
47, was questioned by a judge but has not been charged at this
time. Prosecutors believe he may have been unaware of the infants
because Dominique's obesity concealed the pregnancies.
Dominique and Pierre-Marie Cottrez are also the
parents of 2 adult daughters who are currently in their 20's.
Dominique Cottrez
June 1, 2013
Dominique Cottrez, the
Frenchwoman who confessed in 2010 to killing eight of her own
newborn babies, has been freed under supervision, French media
report.
She was released untagged by an appeals court
in the northern town of Douai on condition she continued to
receive psychological and psychiatric care.
Mrs Cottrez had been in custody since July
2010, when remains were found in the garden of her parents' home.
She was awaiting trial on eight charges of
voluntary homicide.
It was not immediately clear on what grounds
she had been released.
JBurke
French woman accused of
killing 8 newborns 'very distressed'
CNN.com
July 30, 2010
A French woman who admitted to giving birth to
and then smothering eight babies over a 17-year period is "falling
apart," according to her attorney.
Lawyer Frank Berton told CNN Friday the woman,
Dominique Cottrez, was "psychologically very distressed. She is
depressed and falling apart. However, she admits to the crimes and
she even helped the police discover the bodies."
Cottrez told investigators she killed the
babies because she did not want to have any more children and did
not want to see doctors for contraceptives, prosecutor Eric
Vaillant told reporters Thursday. Cottrez is overweight and was
able to conceal the pregnancies, he said. On Thursday, prosecutors
said they had charged her with murder.
"She has been plagued by this for a long time
and now she is relieved," Attorney Burton said. "My client will be
undergoing psychological tests and treatment to try and understand
what pushed her to commit these murders." Burton speculated on one
reason: "I believe she could have suffered from pregnancy denial."
Burton said Cottrez was a nurse assistant. "She comes from a
conventional background. Something went very wrong. One cannot
spiral down into horror without an explanation."
Cottrez was secretive but always supportive of
her family, two of her daughters said in a local newspaper report
published Friday.
"It's incomprehensible," Virginie, 21, told La
Voix du Nord newspaper.
Cottrez said she hid the pregnancies and deaths
from her husband, Vaillant said. And daughters Virginie and
Emeline, who came to court to support their mother Thursday, told
La Voix du Nord they were also shocked by the news.
"We never noticed anything. She had moments of
fatigue, it's true, but she was working almost 24 hours a day. She
would wake up early for her work as a nurse's home aid, and when
she would return home, she had her housework," the newspaper
reported the daughters' saying.
They described their mother as a caring person
who often babysat her grandchildren.
"For us, it's something that one sees on
television, but not in a little town like ours," Emeline said,
according to La Voix du Nord.
The case came to light when a couple gardening
in their backyard in the northern town of Villers-au-Tertre found
two babies' bodies in sealed plastic bags and called police.
As word spread and reporters descended on the
village, which local media have said has a population of about 700
people, residents said they were still reeling from the news.
Cottrez, 45, grew up in Villers-au-Tertre. Her
parents, farmers who are now dead, owned a large part of the
arable land in the village, according to La Voix du Nord.
Thursday morning, the village priest left eight
candles in front of the door to the couple's home, La Voix du Nord
reported.
Police spoke to Cottrez and her husband, who
had previously lived in the home, and Cottrez admitted immediately
that she was the mother of the two babies the couple found
gardening, Vaillant said. She then told police about six others
concealed in their garage, Vaillant said.
Those six bodies were also in sealed plastic
bags but were covered by various objects, he said.
Cottrez's attorney said Friday she denies
burying the babies. "She is adamant about the fact that she did
not bury the babies in the garden. She also says it is definitely
not her husband. We don't know who did it but she is certain she
didn't do it and neither did her husband," Burton said.
The babies were born between 1989 and 2006, but
their exact birthdates aren't known, Vaillant said.
Cottrez had psychological problems from her
first pregnancy, said Pierre-Jean Gribouva, the lawyer for her
husband.
"My client is in a deep state of shock,"
Gribouva told CNN affiliate BFM. "He had no idea about this. He
has totally fallen apart."
A difficult first pregnancy sparked Cottrez's
actions, Vaillant said. Because of her weight, the first pregnancy
was "traumatic," and she didn't want to go through it again, he
said.
Vaillaint did not explain why Cottrez went
through a second pregnancy with her other daughter before
apparently committing the crimes.
The father, Pierre-Marie Cottrez, hopes the
public does not make "simplistic conclusions" about his wife,
Gribouva told BFM.
Despite reports that the husband had been
charged, Vaillant said he was free to go but may still be
investigated. Vaillant said he personally still had "doubts" about
the father's story.
"The sky has fallen in on his head," Vaillant
said of the father.
French Woman Jailed After
Confessing She Killed her Eight Infants
By Christophe Schpoliansky -
ABCNews.go.com
July 29, 2010
Eight candles burned today in front of the
"house of horror" in Villers-au-Tertre, a quiet little village in
northern France that was stunned to learn that a villager has
admitted to giving birth to eight children and then smothering
them.
Six of the tiny corpses were found in plastic
bags stored in her garage, while two others were buried in the
garden of an adjacent yard.
Dominique Cottrez, a 45-year-old nursing
assistant, has confessed to killing her eight newborn children at
birth and hiding their bodies, police told a news conference
today. She is in jail after a judge placed her under formal
investigation, one step away from being formally charged for
"voluntary murder of minors under the age of 15."
Her husband, Pierre-Marie, a 47-year-old
carpenter, was questioned by a judge, but has not been charged
with any crime. He remains free. The couple has two other
daughters in their 20s.
"The mother, Madame Cottrez, has admitted to
having voluntarily suffocated (to death) the newborns at birth
between 1989 and 2006 or 2007," Eric Vaillant, the public
prosecutor of Douai, told the news conference.
"Monsieur Cottrez told investigators that he
never knew his wife was pregnant as she is rather stout or that
she got rid of the children immediately following their births "
Vaillant said. "His whole world turned upside down" when the
husband found out, the prosecutor said. "Madame Cottrez has
confirmed her husband's accounts."
The grisly discoveries began on Saturday when a
couple who was gardening found the bodies of two infants buried in
their garden. They immediately alerted the gendarmes, and the
couple was quickly cleared of any wrongdoing.
The investigation then focused on the previous
owners of the house, the now-deceased parents of Dominique
Cottrez. Questioned as a witness, Cottrez quickly confessed to
killing the two infants found in the garden. She then pointed
investigators to the other six bodies in her garage.
Dominique Cottrez Did Not Want Any More
Children
"She explained she did not want to have any
more children and that she did not want to see a doctor to obtain
a method of contraception" Vaillant said. "Due to her stoutness,
her first childbirth did not go well at all. And because of this,
she did not want to see a doctor."
It is now up to the investigating judge to
request psychological, psychiatric and medical examinations,
notably to determine Cottrez's level of criminal responsibility.
"There are numerous remaining investigations
that need to be done to try to understand, without excusing her,
what led Madame Cottrez to act this way," the prosecutor said. "We
are in the presence of an extraordinary case considering the
number of newborns."
The 700 residents of the usually quiet farming
village of Villers-au-Tertre were in shock.
"They were very friendly, nice, devoted, always
helpful. I don't understand," the Rev. Robert Meignotte, the
village's priest, told reporters outside the house where he had
placed the memorial candles.
"She had not much contacts with the
population," Mayor Patrick Mercier told reporters in front of city
hall. "He was a lot more extrovert. He was a member of the
village's recreation committee" and the local council, Mercier
said, referring to the husband.
It is the lastest case of infanticide in
France. In March, a 38-year-old woman was sentenced to 15 years in
prison for killing six babies at birth between 2000 and 2007.
Another Frenchwoman was convicted last year of
murdering three of her newborn children. She was sentenced to
eight years in prison. Her husband discovered two of the corpses
in a freezer while the two were living in South Korea. During the
trial psychiatrists testified that she suffered from a
psychological condition known as "pregnancy denial."
Woman charged in France
over babies' bodies
CNN.com
July 29, 2010
French prosecutors said Thursday they charged a
woman with murder after she admitted giving birth to and
smothering eight babies over a 17-year period in northern France.
The woman, Dominique Cottrez, said she hid the
pregnancies and deaths from her husband, who said he had no idea
what she had done, prosecutor Eric Vaillant told reporters.
Cottrez is overweight and was able to conceal the pregnancies, he
said.
Cottrez told investigators the reason she
killed the babies was that she did not want to have any more
children and did not want to see doctors for contraceptives,
Vaillant said.
Despite earlier reports that the husband had
been charged, Vaillant said he was free to go but may still be
investigated. Vaillant said he personally still had "doubts" about
the father's story.
"The sky has fallen in on his head," Vaillant
said of the father, Pierre-Marie Cottrez. "He indicated he had no
idea she was pregnant."
Vaillant said there are no other babies' bodies
left to be found.
The case came to light when a couple gardening
in their backyard in the northern town of Villers-au-Tertre found
two babies' bodies in sealed plastic bags and called police.
Police spoke to Cottrez and her husband, who
had previously lived in the home, and Cottrez admitted immediately
that she was the mother of the two babies, Vaillant said. She then
told police about six others concealed in their garage, Vaillant
said.
Those six bodies were also in sealed plastic
bags but were covered by various objects, he said.
Cottrez, a nurse, had psychological problems
from her first pregnancy, said Pierre-Jean Gribouva, the lawyer
for her husband.
"My client is in a deep state of shock,"
Gribouva told CNN affiliate BFM. "He had no idea about this. He
has totally fallen apart."
The babies were born between 1989 and 2006, but
their exact birthdates aren't known, Vaillant said.
"She knew that she was pregnant every time, and
she has admitted this," Vaillant said. Cottrez "answered in a very
straightforward way."
Cottrez and her husband have two adult
daughters, but it was a difficult first pregnancy that sparked her
actions, Vaillant said. Because of her weight, the first pregnancy
was "traumatic," and she didn't want to go through it again, he
said.
Vaillaint did not explain why Cottrez went
through a second pregnancy with her other daughter before
apparently committing the crimes.
Pierre-Marie Cottrez hopes the public does not
make "simplistic conclusions" about his wife, Gribouva told BFM.
The family members "are supporting the wife and
the mother because they realize she has serious problems," he
said. "There is no rejection of her as a wife and mother."
Psychotherapist Lucy Beresford told CNN that
very little was known about incidences of infanticide because it
was a taboo subject. A paper published in the Journal of the
American Medical Association by researchers in North Carolina
estimated that 2.1 cases of infanticide occurred for every 100,000
births, but Beresford said the body of psychological research was
"slim."
Research suggested that women who denied or
concealed their pregnancies, for whatever reason, were a
"high-risk" group, she said. But other factors could trigger
infanticide as well.
"It could actually be to do with the social
isolation of the mother, or it could be their psychopathology
prior to pregnancy," Beresford told CNN.
"For example, do they have a history of
substance abuse or other mental health concerns that have
contributed to them being in this situation which they cannot
accept as a reality?"
Postnatal depression could also be a possible
contributory factor, she said.
"That could be because when they're depressed
they're not really of sound mind. It could be that they genuinely
believe they are unworthy to be a parent. Or it could just be the
level of disordered thinking that comes with being depressed."
Details emerge in French baby killing case
BBC.co.uk
July 29, 2010
Details have emerged of the woman detained in France over one of
biggest infanticide cases in the country's recent history.
People who know Dominique Cottrez, a nursing
assistant, say she is a woman with a weight problem who played
little part in the life of her village near Lille,
Villers-au-Tertre.
Her husband, Pierre-Marie Cottrez, is a
carpenter who, by contrast, has sat on the village council for
years. He is a "decent, well-meaning type", according to Mayor
Patrick Mercier.
The couple, in their 40s, have two grown-up
children, both daughters now in their 20s, with children of their
own.
Before news of their arrest, it was the common
view that the Cottrez couple were "des gens sans histoire", or
"quiet people".
Mrs Cottrez has now confessed to killing eight
of her own newborn babies, apparently because of memories of
difficulties during her first pregnancy.
Her husband was initially detained on suspicion
of failing to report the crimes but was later released without
charge.
'Would not hurt a
fly'
When the people of Villers-au-Tertre,
population 655, saw police teams descending on their village some
thought an alarm must have been raised over "something left over
from the war".
The village serves commuters for towns like
Douai and Cambrai in the Nord region and is described by one of
them as a "quiet, peaceful" place set deep in the countryside.
Mrs Cottrez was born and educated in the
village, local newspaper La Voix du Nord reports. Her two grown
daughters still live locally, French media say.
It was at a house on Rue de Fressain which once
belonged to her parents that two baby skeletons were found, when
the new owners were digging up their garden to put in a pool.
Police traced the find back to the Cottrez
couple, who had sold the property, and the mother confessed to
having suffocated eight of her own babies.
The remains of the other six were found at the
couple's current address on Sentier du Pre, inside plastic bags
which had been placed in a fuel storage tank.
This property, where the couple had been living
for the past 17 years, is described by La Voix du Nord as a
modern-looking, detached house.
Mayor Mercier says the mother rarely ventured
out of it. Her weight problem, he told AFP news agency, may have
accounted for the fact that her pregnancies had passed unnoticed.
One unnamed neighbour described the mother as a
"shy" person who was "very fat" while a teenage girl who knows the
two daughters said their mother was a "discreet, simple woman who
would not hurt a fly".
'Difficult first
birth'
Mrs Cottrez, who faces life imprisonment,
insisted her husband had known nothing about either the
pregnancies or the killings, an official close to the
investigation told AFP.
"She explains that she did not want any more
children and that she did not want to see a doctor about methods
of contraception," a spokesman for prosecutors told reporters.
Her first delivery had been "difficult because
of her large body weight and for that reason she did not want to
see a doctor".
As villagers continued to voice their
astonishment at the crimes uncovered, local priest Father Robert
Meignotte spoke of his horror.
"I'm thinking of all the children [in the
world] who didn't ask to be born and were thrown out a few hours
later," he said.
"I'm very upset. I baptise five children every
Sunday in the 17 villages of the parish. You don't just throw
children out like that... It's incomprehensible."
Multiple
infanticide cases
The phenomenon of multiple infanticide is
nothing new in modern France, where at least a dozen cases have
come to light since 1984, according to AFP.
In March of this year, a
mother confessed to killing six of her newborn children over eight
years and hiding them in the cellar of her house in Valognes,
north-west France.
In 1984 a couple in Correze, central France,
were jailed for killing seven of their newborn infants over a
period of seven years.
And the French newspaper La Depeche mentions a
trial in the 1970s when a farming couple in the Nord region were
convicted of killing nine babies.
"At the time, there was talk of a method of
spontaneous contraception," court psychiatrist Dr Daniel Ajzenberg
told the paper.
Experts say infanticide cases often involve
"denial of pregnancy", when women refuse to accept they are
pregnant.
About 500 such cases are recorded each year
around the world, Professor Israel Nisand of the University
Hospital in Strasbourg told Reuters news agency.
One of the most notorious cases was in Germany
in 2006, when a mother was sentenced to 15 years in prison for the
manslaughter of eight of her newborn babies. A ninth baby had also
died but too much time had lapsed to allow a prosecution.
Dominique Cottrez did not cite denial of
pregnancy as a motive in her case, French prosecutors said.